News & Resources

The 10 Most Expensive Cities in Ontario for Car Insurance

Jan. 6, 2021
4 mins
Two hands grip the steering wheel of a car

It’s no secret that Ontario is one of the most expensive provinces in Canada for insurance rates, and unfortunately, those costs continue to rise. What’s more, drivers who live in the Greater Toronto Area (GTA), including the City of Toronto, pay more for car insurance than drivers elsewhere in the province.

In 2018, the average Ontario auto insurance premium was estimated to be $1,473 per year. In 2020, and according to RATESDOTCA’s Insuramap, the average premium was approximately $1,616 annually, a 9.7% increase from two years ago.

Insuramap is an interactive online map that lets you search for the average auto insurance rate in a city or neighbourhood by postal code.

The Financial Services Regulatory Authority (FSRA), Ontario’s insurance regulator, allowed insurers in the province to offer rebates and premium discounts totalling an estimated $1 billion in savings for drivers to help soften the economic impact of the COVID-19 pandemic in 2020. However, FSRA did allow some insurers to increase their rates during the year.

car mascot.png

Don't waste time calling around for auto insurance

Use RATESDOTCA to shop around, and compare multiple quotes at the same time.

Why Ontario car insurance rates are increasing

There are a variety of reasons as to why auto policy premiums rise independent of an individual driver’s record. Insurance fraud, an increase in claims in the region you live, the escalating cost of repairing modern vehicles, as well as collisions caused by distracted driving all contribute to higher premiums for all.

According to the Insurance Bureau of Canada, more than half of every dollar insurance companies receive is used to settle claims. As claims cost increases, so too do insurance rates.

Which cities in Ontario have the most expensive car insurance rates?

If you reside in the GTA, you may likely be paying more than the provincial average of $1,616. These cities have the most expensive premiums in Ontario:

MostExpON.jpg

Rank City Estimated Premium
1. Brampton $2,698
2. Mississauga $2,372
3. Vaughan $2.334
4. Richmond Hill $2,286
5. Markham $2,222
6. Toronto $2,201
7. Ajax $2,141
8. Pickering $1,961
9. Whitby $1,777
10. Hamilton $1,755

The rate estimates in the above chart are based on a 35-year-old driver of a 2017 Honda Civic with a clean driving record.

Do large cities have higher rates?

The GTA is the most populous region in the country, home to more than 6 million people in 2020. It is projected to be the fastest-growing region in Ontario and is forecast to grow to over 9.5 million people by 2045.

The populations in other regions just outside of the GTA – Durham, Halton, Peel and York – are also forecast to rise higher than the provincial average. For instance, Peel Region (consisting of Brampton, Caledon, and Mississauga) is expected to welcome 900,000 new residents by 2046, which is a 59.2% increase from 2019. In other words, there are millions of drivers in the GTA, and there will be more vehicles on the road over time.

Despite this, it’s not necessarily your city’s population that determines what your insurance rate will be. Otherwise, cities like London, Windsor, Kitchener and Ottawa would factor into the 10 most expensive urban centres. According to Insuramap, each of these four cities has insurance premiums lower than the provincial average:

  • The average insurance premium in London is $1,509 (up from $1,392 in 2018).
  • The average insurance premium in Windsor is $1,412 (up from $1,368 in 2018).
  • The average insurance premium in Kitchener is $1,341 (up from $1,264 in 2018).
  • The average insurance premium in Ottawa is $1,213 per year (up from $1,151 in 2018).

Why insurance rates vary geographically

Auto policy premiums vary by town or city for a variety of reasons, but it ultimately comes down to assessing the likelihood of filing a claim. If the municipality where you live has a greater frequency of insurance claims than others, or if claims costs trend higher in that region, your premium is likely to reflect that.

However, where you live may no longer factor into your insurance premium in the not-too-distant future. In its 2018 Ontario Economic Outlook and Fiscal Review, the provincial government said it would explore a variety of ways to lower rates, including eliminating geography-based pricing.

There is legislation called, “Ending Discrimination in Automobile Insurance Act 2019” (referred to as Bill 42), that would remove your postal code from insurers’ calculations when determining what you pay for coverage. As of December 2020, Bill 42 is under review by Ontario’s Standing Committee on Finance and Economic Affairs. Should the Committee approve of it, it will get a third reading in the Legislative Assembly of Ontario, and if passed, it will receive royal assent and become law.

Which cities in Ontario have the cheapest car insurance rates?

To get an auto policy premium below the provincial average of $1,616, you need to live in a city or region outside of the GTA. According to RATESDOTCA’s data, here are the towns or cities in Ontario with populations greater than 15,000 people that have the cheapest car insurance rates in 2020:

  • Grimsby and Waterdown have an average rate of $1,192 per year.
  • Sudbury has an average rate of $1,165 per year.
  • Sarnia has an average rate of $1,159 per year.
  • St. Thomas has an average rate of $1,124 per year.
  • Cornwall, Petawawa, and Russell have an average rate of $1,107 per year.
  • Kingston, Napanee, Port Hope, Cobourg and Brockville all have an average rate of $1,103 per year.

Other smaller urban centres such as Collingwood, Owen Sound, and Stratford ($1,211 per year each) also all fall below the provincial average.

How to lower your Ontario auto insurance rate no matter where you live

From large urban centres to smaller towns, there are many ways Ontario’s drivers can save money on their insurance premiums, including:

  • Maintain a clean driving record. Tickets and collisions can affect your premiums for years.
  • Bundle your policies. If you buy your car and home insurance policies from the same provider, you can typically save between 5% to 15%.
  • Install winter tires. All Ontario insurers have to offer a discount to drivers who change their tires seasonally that could save you as much as 5%.
  • Increase your policy deductibles. Upping your coverage deductibles can lower your annual premium. However, be sure to set your deductibles to an amount you can comfortably afford as this is the portion of a claim that you’ll have to pay.
  • Sign up for usage-based insurance. There are two types of usage-based insurance programs available in Canada, commonly known as pay-as-you-go and pay-how-you-drive, respectively. Each offers drivers the opportunity to pay less for insurance, and both types provide an enrollment discount ranging from 5% to 10%.

Last but not least, get into the habit of shopping your rate regularly (at least once a year before your policy is up for renewal). Comparing policies and premiums is a smart way to find the coverage you need at the best price. It’s also free, and it only takes a few clicks to get quotes from a broad range of insurers, so you can see what the price differences are based on your driving profile.

Liam Lahey

Liam Lahey is a versatile, seasoned writer and editor. He worked as both a staff writer and freelance writer for many business and technology publications as well as for several newspapers. He writes about home, auto, and travel insurance, and is a media spokesperson for RATESDOTCA.

LinkedIn

Latest auto articles

What You Need to Know About No-Fault Insurance in Ontario
The term "no-fault insurance" is confusing. Does it mean no one is to blame for a car accident? Not exactly.
How to Get Your Car Ready for Winter and Avoid Road Emergencies This Year
Taking steps to get your vehicle winter-ready involves installing snow tires, clearing all the snow and ice off your vehicle, and driving carefully.
What Is an Insurance Grace Period?
Falling behind on your insurance bill can be stressful and costly. Here’s what you need to know about the insurance grace period.