Ask the mortgage expert: How homebuyers can uncover savings as builders survive high costs

Ask the Expert is a monthly column where Steve Garganis, lead mortgage planner at Mortgage Architects and founder of CanadaMortgageNews.ca dives into what’s going on with mortgage rates and the Canadian housing market. Have a question for Steve on home buying and your mortgage? Reach out to us at media@rates.ca.
Buyers often hear about softening home prices, a slow housing market across Canada, and an impending real estate crash. Yet brand new homes aren’t getting significantly cheaper. The current real estate landscape is a complex web of institutional messaging, soaring construction costs, government initiatives, and builder survival tactics rooted in lessons learned from past market downturns.
Historical data shows how developers adjust pricing to survive during periods of high raw material costs. Understanding these builder survival tactics can help homebuyers save money.
Tracing the myth of a ‘National Crash' between 1989–2026
Many potential buyers tend to sit on the sidelines waiting for a catastrophic housing crash to reset prices back to where they were a decade ago. The 35-year trendline of major repricing cycles from the late 1980s onward, where average home prices in Canada swung by more than 5% in either direction, tells a different story.
Data indicates expectations of a ’National Crash’ that permanently resets prices across the board for all housing types has been a flawed assumption. Real estate is a long-term investment.
Average home prices across major Canadian cities
Shows % change in price since the prior cycle peak/dip.
| Year & market phase | Toronto | Vancouver | Calgary | Montreal | Halifax |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1989 (Late '80s peak) | $273,698 | $213,000 | $109,000 | $115,000 | $85,000 |
| 1996 ('90s bottom) | $198,150 -27.6% | $291,000 +36.6% | $132,000 +21.1% | $122,000 +6.1% | $95,000 +11.8% |
| 2006 (Pre-crisis boom) | $351,941 +77.6% | $482,000 +65.6% | $319,000 +141.7% | $220,000 +80.3% | $160,000 +68.4% |
| 2008 (Financial crisis) | $379,347 +7.8% | $593,000 +23.0% | $405,000 +27.0% | $240,000 +9.1% | $204,000 +27.5% |
| 2017 (Pre-stress test peak) | $822,510 +116.8% | $1,030,000 +73.7% | $432,000 +6.7% | $318,000 +32.5% | $289,000 +41.7% |
| 2020 (COVID-19 start) | $929,692 +13.0% | $1,036,000 +0.6% | $417,000 -3.5% | $429,000 +34.9% | $379,000 +31.1% |
| 2021 (The surge) | $1,095,333 +17.8% | $1,186,000 +14.5% | $451,000 +8.2% | $508,000 +18.4% | $465,000 +22.7% |
| 2022 (The peak) | $1,189,850 +8.6% | $1,262,600 +6.5% | $529,000 +17.3% | $552,000 +8.7% | $530,000 +14.0% |
| 2023 (Rate hike correction) | $1,126,604 -5.3% | $1,188,000 -5.9% | $553,000 +4.5% | $521,000 -5.6% | $528,000 -0.4% |
| 2024 (Stagnation) | $1,090,900 -3.2% | $1,184,000 -0.3% | $612,838 +10.8% | $540,000 +3.6% | $565,000 +7.0% |
| 2026 (Today's market) | $1,084,547 -0.6% (3Y: -3.7%) | $1,191,200 +0.6% (3Y: +0.3%) | $638,440 +4.2% (3Y: +15.5%) | $560,000 +3.7% (3Y: +7.5%) | $590,786 +4.6% (3Y: +11.9%) |
Source: Toronto Regional Real Estate Board, Real Estate Board of Greater Vancouver, Calgary Real Estate Board, Nova Scotia Association of Realtors
In the last four years, the overall market in Toronto and Vancouver experienced a noticeable drop from the 2022 peak. But Calgary and Halifax ignored the broader correction, marching steadily upward due to interprovincial migration and intense supply shortages.
Learn more: Why Canadian housing seems unaffordable in 2026: A 35-year real estate disconnect
Mapping the condo rollercoaster of price swings and erased equity
Real estate is hyper-local and highly segmented. While detached home prices have remained relatively insulated, the apartment condo market has been a rollercoaster.
Historical data of average prices shows immense volatility in the condo sector across similar Canadian cities and timelines.
Average condo prices across major Canadian cities
Shows % change in price since the prior cycle peak/dip
| Year & market phase | Toronto condos | Vancouver condos | Calgary condos | Montreal condos | Halifax condos |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1989 (Late '80s peak) | $152,000 | $145,000 | $65,000 | $75,000 | $55,000 |
| 1996 ('90s bottom) | $115,000 -24.3% | $165,000 +13.8% | $85,000 +30.8% | $80,000 +6.7% | $65,000 +18.2% |
| 2006 (Pre-crisis boom) | $235,000 +104.3% | $280,000 +69.7% | $210,000 +147.1% | $155,000 +93.8% | $115,000 +76.9% |
| 2008 (Financial crisis) | $255,000 +8.5% | $335,000 +19.6% | $260,000 +23.8% | $175,000 +12.9% | $140,000 +21.7% |
| 2017 (Pre-stress test peak) | $510,000 +100.0% | $605,000 +80.6% | $275,000 +5.8% | $245,000 +40.0% | $195,000 +39.3% |
| 2020 (COVID-19 start) | $625,000 +22.5% | $674,000 +11.4% | $245,000 -10.9% | $315,000 +28.6% | $260,000 +33.3% |
| 2021 (The surge) | $710,000 +13.6% | $740,000 +9.8% | $260,000 +6.1% | $360,000 +14.3% | $315,000 +21.2% |
| 2022 (The peak) | $840,000 +18.3% | $846,000 +14.3% | $285,000 +9.6% | $405,000 +12.5% | $375,000 +19.0% |
| 2023 (Rate hike correction) | $750,000 -10.7% | $790,000 -6.6% | $310,000 +8.8% | $385,000 -4.9% | $385,000 +2.7% |
| 2024 (Stagnation) | $710,000 -5.3% | $770,000 -2.5% | $335,000 +8.1% | $395,000 +2.6% | $410,000 +6.5% |
| 2026 (Today's market) | $630,000 -11.3% (3Y: -16.0%) | $685,000 -11.0% (3Y: -13.3%) | $355,000 +6.0% (3Y: +14.5%) | $410,000 +3.8% (3Y: +6.5%) | $435,000 +6.1% (3Y: +13.0%) |
Source: Toronto Regional Real Estate Board, Real Estate Board of Greater Vancouver, Calgary Real Estate Board, Nova Scotia Association of Realtors
Institutional messaging supports CMHC's stability narrative
Federal Crown corporation Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation (CMHC) emphasizes systemic stability highlighting low national delinquency rates to maintain consumer confidence. However, 90-day mortgage delinquencies have spiked in key markets like Ontario.
Major bank economic divisions—such as TD Economics and RBC Economics—frequently publish housing outlooks forecasting pipeline stagnation and rate trajectories. Canada's chartered banks hold significant lending exposure from developer construction loans as well as consumer residential mortgages. Projections from bank analysts often advocate for monetary policy stances that protect credit volume and prevent systemic developer defaults.
Government initiatives muddle real estate market dynamics
The divergence between falling home resale values and fixed pre-construction contract prices has created severe pressure for recent buyers. Pre-construction homebuyers who signed contracts at market peaks are encountering significant appraisal shortfalls at final closing. New builds purchased for $950,000 are in some cases valued $200,000 to $400,000 lower, requiring homebuyers to supply substantial additional cash equity or face legal default.
Price stagnation of the last few years has led to oversupply of new housing stock in some major Canadian cities. Public taxpayer-funded government initiatives have stepped in to support unsold stock. For instance, multi-billion-dollar government funding to purchase unsold new home inventory directly from developers absorbs excess supply without requiring baseline price cuts. These initiatives maintain construction activity, socialize developer risks, and keep registered house prices artificially high.
Why prices can't drop amidst high costs of raw materials
Beyond government actions, another reason new build homes are not getting cheaper is the non-negotiable cost of land, labor, and raw materials. Data from Statistics Canada’s Building Construction Price Index (BCPI) confirms that it is unfeasible for builders to slash new-build prices to match resale condo values without insolvent outcomes.
Here is a breakdown of specific material cost increases pressuring developers today compared to 2020 baselines, ordered by highest percentage increases:
| Construction material | % price change since 2020 | Primary drivers of cost inflation |
|---|---|---|
| Copper (electrical/wiring) | +62% | Global demand surges for electric vehicles and green energy grids competing for raw copper |
| Structural steel | +55% | Global supply chain fracturing, tariffs, and high energy costs for smelting |
| Ready-mix concrete | +48% | Rising carbon taxes, aggregate shortages, and heavy transportation costs |
| Plumbing & fixtures | +38% | Manufacturing delays and increased costs for PVC and raw plastics |
| Lumber & wood products | +35% | Highly volatile; heavily impacted by mill closures and forestry sector labour shortages |
Source: Statistics Canada, Canadian Home Builders' Association (CHBA): Housing Market Index Data & Construction Material Cost Reports
Data from Verisk Analytics’ Q3 2026 Reconstruction Cost Analysis report further underscores these raw material price pressures. Over the past year, total residential reconstruction costs increased by 4.2% across Canada, with overall building materials up 3.8% and labor costs rising by 4.6%. These escalations highlight the high replacement costs that prevent developers from lowering baseline prices.
When concrete is up nearly 50% and copper wiring is up over 60%, a developer’s profit margin would evaporate. Builders are hard pressed to slash sticker prices to 2020 levels as they would be building at a loss.
How builders orchestrate an ‘invisible’ price cut
Why don't builders simply lower official sticker prices by $100,000 to clear slow inventory? It boils down to strict mechanics of developer bank financing covenants. Developers rely on substantial senior construction loans from major financial institutions. To maintain loan draw eligibility, lenders mandate strict pre-sale thresholds at specified minimum price-per-square-foot benchmarks.
If a developer lowers registered sticker prices across a project, they would violate bank covenants, jeopardize debt financing, potentially prompt revolts from earlier buyers, and undermine bank appraisals across the entire development.
To survive slow periods while protecting official project valuations, builders employ three primary structural strategies refined since the 1990s:
- Phased inventory releases: Releasing small tranches of units strictly as needed, and holding back unsold inventory to prevent market flooding, can artificially support price floors.
- Project pauses and deferrals: Delaying formal sales launches or site servicing on upcoming phases until market absorption rates improve, can limit new supply additions.
- Available incentives: Offering substantial concessions—such as developer fee caps, mortgage rate buy-downs, design credits, and tax rebates—potentially reduces net purchase prices by 10% to 15% without altering registered title prices.
How to uncover hidden incentives when buying a new home
Because builders must protect official project valuations, buyers can secure major financial advantages by targeting available concessions. Upfront development levies are municipal fees charged to developers for local infrastructure and services, which are typically passed directly on to buyers as closing costs.
The table below demonstrates the 5-year financial impact of negotiating a mortgage rate buy-down (reducing the initial rate from 5.0% to 3.0% for the first two years to lower monthly payments and total out-of-pocket costs) along with capped development levies on a standard $600,000 pre-construction mortgage:
| Expense category | Standard purchase (5.0% rate) | Negotiated incentives (3.0% buy-down + waived levies) | Total saved |
|---|---|---|---|
| Upfront levies (municipal closing fees) | $20,000 | $0 | $20,000 |
| Monthly payment (Yrs. 1–2 subsidized) | $3,489.63 | $2,839.47 | $650.16/month |
| Monthly payment (Yrs. 3–5 standard rate) | $3,489.63 | $3,489.63 | $0 |
| Total 5-year out-of-pocket cost | $229,378 | $193,774 | $35,604 |
Read more: Ask the mortgage expert: What a U.S. Fed rate hike could imply for Canadian mortgage rates
How to negotiate with builders when buying a new home
Understanding developer survival tactics allows buyers to negotiate aggressively for structural terms that directly lower out-of-pocket costs.
Here are a list of actionable negotiation strategies:
- Cap development levies at zero: Municipalities charge significant development levies that can unexpectedly increase closing costs by tens of thousands of dollars. Insist that development levies are capped at zero or your builder absorbs them entirely.
- Demand price protection guarantees: Require a price protection clause in your contract stating that if your developer subsequently lowers prices for your unit layout prior to occupancy, you would receive an equivalent closing credit.
- Negotiate mortgage rate buy-downs: Require your builder to provide upfront cash credits at closing to subsidize your mortgage interest rate for the initial 1 to 2 years of your loan term. In other words, the builder provides cash upfront to temporarily lower your interest rate (for example, dropping a 5% rate down to 3% for the first two years), significantly reducing your monthly payments while keeping the officially registered purchase price intact.
- Secure extended deposit schedules: Instead of paying 20% down within 180 days, negotiate spreading deposit installments across 3 to 4 years to preserve your liquidity, while you could earn interest on your capital.
- Obtain free right of assignment: Ensure your developer waives standard $5,000 to $10,000 assignment fees, providing a penalty-free exit option to transfer your contract prior to final closing if necessary.
- Maximize upgrades and closing credits: Demand flat closing credits to offset legal and transfer taxes, alongside included parking, storage lockers, and premium interior finish allowances.
Buying a home in the current landscape can seem like embarking on a lifetime of debt. But despite historically high replacement costs, today's soft market—a four-year market correction and urban condo prices reverting to 2020 levels, can offer a window of opportunity.
If you’re looking at a new build, consult your mortgage broker before signing a contract to run through available strategies that can ensure you aren't leaving money on the table.
Read next: How interest rate changes affect your variable-rate mortgage
Compare Mortgage Rates
Engaging a mortgage broker before renewing can help you make a better decision. Mortgage brokers are an excellent source of information for deals specific to your area, contract terms, and their services require no out-of-pocket fees if you are well qualified.
Here at Rates.ca, we compare rates from the best Canadian mortgage brokers, major banks and dozens of smaller competitors.










