Cheapest Cars to Insure

Buying a car? Your guide to the cheapest cars to insure in Canada!

The cheapest cars to insure in Canada

The cheapest cars to insure in Canada

When it comes to auto insurance in Canada, many factors determine your annual premium. One of the most influential factors is the car you drive. The top two things insurers take into consideration when it comes to your vehicle are its safety rating and the likelihood of it getting stolen.

+ Expand

Which cars are the safest to drive?

Each year, the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) analyses the relevant data, drawn from driver fatalities, crash test results, headlight ratings and other metrics to draw up a list of the safest cars. Vehicles are divided into the following categories: small cars, midsize cars, midsize luxury cars, large cars, large luxury cars, small SUVs, midsize SUVs, midsize luxury SUVs, large SUVs and large pickups. The list is updated each year. Here is a selection of the most recent winners in each category:

Small cars 2019-20 Honda Insight 4-door sedan
Midsize cars 2019-20 Toyota Camry 4-door sedan
Midsize luxury cars 2019-20 BMW 3 series 4-door sedan
Large cars 2019-20 Kia Stinger 4-door hatchback
Large luxury cars 2019-20 Audi A6 4-door sedan
Small SUVs 2019-20 Toyota RAV4 4-door SUV
Midsize SUVs 2019-20 Volkswagen Tiguan 4-door SUV
Midsize luxury SUVs 2019 Mercedes-Benz GLC 4-door SUV
Large SUVs 2019 Audi e-tron 4-door SUV
Large pickups 2019-20 Ram 1500 Crew cab pickup

The full list is available on the IIHS website.

When it comes to your vehicle: size matters

When it comes to your vehicle: size matters

Heavier vehicles offer more protection than smaller ones, so insurance companies will save the cheapest rates for midsize and large cars. These cars possess very durable frames and are unlikely to collapse in on themselves following a collision, ultimately keeping the occupants safer than the lighter frames found on smaller cars.

There is an intervening connotation here too; insurance companies consider SUVs and minivans to be family cars, and thus more likely to have a sensible, cautious driver than a “souped up” sports car, for example.

Aside from the make and model of your car, insurers also consider the age of the car when assessing its safety. Newer cars have the most safety features, but they also cost the most money to repair and replace. Each insurance company will assess the likelihood of you needing to make a claim, and how much that claim is likely to cost, before giving you a quote for car insurance.

+ Expand

Which cars are at greatest risk of theft?

It is not a secret that your postal code affects your insurance premium. If you live in an area with a high rate of auto theft, car insurance coverage will cost more.

Each year, the Insurance Bureau of Canada releases its list of the 10 most stolen vehicles. If your car is on this list, even if you live in an area with a low crime rate, you could face a higher insurance premium. In 2019, the most stolen vehicles in Canada were:

  1. 2007 FORD F350 SD 4WD
  2. 2006 FORD F350 SD 4WD
  3. 2005 FORD F350 SD 4WD
  4. 2004 FORD F350 SD 4WD
  5. 2006 FORD F250 SD 4WD
  6. 2003 FORD F350 SD 4WD
  7. 2018 LEXUS RX350/RX350L/RX450h/RX450hL 4DR AWD
  8. 2005 FORD F250 SD 4WD
  9. 2002 FORD F350 SD 4WD

Look at the most stolen vehicles in your province, and consider other makes and models when buying a new vehicle to get the cheapest insurance.

Saving on car insurance

Saving on car insurance

Vehicles equipped with the most safety features, best crash ratings, and best theft deterrents are the cheapest to insure in Canada. If your car checks these boxes, you can be confident insurance companies will deem it safe and be more willing to offer a cheap insurance premium.

However, there is no substitute for safe, defensive driving. A bad driver in a safe car is still an insurance risk! For the very best deals on car insurance, stick to the rules of the road, maintain a clean driving record, and compare quotes on

+ Expand

Not ready to shop for insurance today?

Let us know your renewal date and we’ll let you know the best time to shop the market for the cheapest car insurance rates.

Latest Articles

Danger: Toronto Housing Is Revving Its Engines Again

Bring your mind back to Toronto’s housing market heydays of 2016. It was a time when double-digit price increases seemed ... Read more

Vehicle Safety Technologies: Helpful or Hindering?

The goal of driver-assist technologies is to make our roads safer, so why aren’t auto insurance rates decreasing? Read more

The Best Way for High-Risk Drivers to Get Car Insurance

Motorists with spotty driving records may have a tough time finding affordable auto insurance. Here’s what you can do about ... Read more

Nicer Wedding or Bigger Down Payment…Which Would You Choose?

Some people spend years dreaming of their wedding day. They plan big, lavish marital events that they hope they’ll never ... Read more