News & Resources

Nearly 70% of Canadians consider repair and replacement costs when buying a vehicle: survey

April 28, 2022
4 mins
A mechanic works under the hood of a vehicle

According to a recent Leger survey conducted on behalf of RATESDOTCA and BNN Bloomberg in April, most Canadians scrutinize costs like possible repairs and auto insurance. However, many will have to adjust their budgets due to availability or high prices.

About one-third of respondents say they purchased a car in the past year or plan to do so soon. Buyers who bought in the past 12 months were mostly men (18%), those between the ages of 18 and 34 (22%), and Canadians living in suburban (18%) and rural (20%) areas.

Rising gas prices and access to public transportation may be driving urbanites to take the subway, while many others might have the privilege of parking their wheels and working from home. Unfortunately for those in the market for a car, supply chain issues are creating months-long wait times for new vehicle orders.

With demand outpacing supply, buyers are also facing a shortage of used vehicles. As of early April, the average used-car price in Canada was slightly below $37,000, according to Canadian Black Book. In some cases, the price tags for used cars are equal to that of new cars.

The survey sought to understand how these challenges influenced Canadians’ car-buying decisions.

Some car buyers will have to make concessions

While most Canadians say they will stick to their plans, many will have to make concessions due to the current market. Sixty percent of Canadians assert that they spent or will spend within their budget; however, many (43%) have made or will make adjustments to their plans.

In fact, 13% said they delayed or would need to delay their purchase due to high prices, while 12% cited availability issues as their reason. Meanwhile, some buyers changed (or expect to change) their choice of a vehicle because of cost (12%) or availability (9%).

Even though Canadians seem open to compromise, vehicle safety and insurance implications are of the utmost importance.


Canadians are making informed car-buying decisions

Despite the lack of choice they have, Canadians are doing their research before car shopping, factoring in overall safety as well as potential risks, such as the likelihood of theft.

Two-thirds (68%) say they will consider the repair and replacement costs when purchasing a car and how it might impact their insurance premium. This factor is most important to those planning to buy a new or used car, at 73% and 76% respectively. In fact, 59% of those who recently bought a new car and 62% who purchased a used car reported being influenced by these details.

Six-in-ten (61%) will consider a vehicle’s safety record or crash rating before buying, while about half will look at the likelihood of accident or theft. Women are more likely to compare all the factors considered in the survey than men, especially regarding crash rating and the probability of an accident.

The survey found that at least two-in-ten respondents were unaware these factors can alter insurance rates.


How your vehicle influences your insurance premium

Auto insurance providers use many factors to determine the premium you pay, including details about your life (e.g., age, gender, home address) and driving experience — essentially, components that determine your likelihood of filing a claim. Your car also influences your rate because different vehicles carry varying claims risks.

Each year, the Insurance Bureau of Canada (IBC) records and analyzes the cost of insurance claims by vehicle make and model using the Canadian Loss Experience Automobile Rating (CLEAR) system. The rankings are broken into four categories:

  • Collision: These claims cover the cost of fixing or replacing a vehicle involved in a crash.
  • Direct compensation property damage (DCPD): These claims also cover the cost of repairs or vehicle replacement.
  • Comprehensive: These claims cover insured perils, such as fire and theft, that don’t result from a collision.
  • Accident benefit (AB): These claims cover injuries to drivers, passengers, or other people involved in a collision.

Industry experts use CLEAR numbers to assess how likely a specific vehicle will be involved in a claim and the cost of damage and any injuries sustained. The data comes entirely from actual insurance claims.

Curious car buyers can also access the CLEAR results on the IBC website to see each vehicle’s rating. A green colour indicates positive rankings, or a lower claims risk, whereas a yellow or red colour indicates negative rankings, or a higher claims risk. Large vehicles, such as pickup trucks, often perform well regarding accident benefit claims; however, many are also popular targets for theft.

A positive CLEAR number could result in a lower auto insurance premium. It is important to note, however, that rankings can change annually. Compare auto insurance quotes upon renewal to ensure you pay the best possible rate.


An online survey of 1,538 Canadians was completed between April 8 and 10, 2022, using Leger’s online panel. No margin of error can be associated with a non-probability sample (i.e., a web panel in this case). For comparative purposes, though, a probability sample of 1,538 respondents would have a margin of error of +/- 2.5%, 19 times out of 20

car mascot.png

Don't waste time calling around for auto insurance

Use RATESDOTCA to shop around, and compare multiple quotes at the same time.

Hayley Vesh

Hayley Vesh is an editor and writer in the personal finance space, where she uses her eight years of media and marketing experience to bring content to life. She specializes in money products, including mortgages, home and auto insurance, and credit cards. Hayley holds a Broadcast Journalism diploma from Sheridan College and was awarded the Shaw Media Journalism and Media Award for graduating at the top of her class. Her work has appeared in Global News and diverse digital corporate training materials behind the scenes.

Hayley is passionate about making complex subjects, such as home buying and financial literacy, concise and intriguing. Her work has garnered media coverage from The Globe and Mail, blogTO, Yahoo! News, and CityNews 680 and has been syndicated across other publications.

Latest auto insurance articles

Is rustproofing worth the added cost?
Learn the pros and cons of rustproofing. Do you really need the service?
Learn More
5 mins read
Right-of-way in Canada: road rules explained
Right-of-way determines which driver has the right to proceed first through an intersection. But it isn’t always obvious. Here’s what you need to know.
Learn More
4 mins read
Your car may be worth less after an accident: Learn about diminished value
In Canada, your insurance does not automatically cover you for any loss in value your vehicle incurs after being repaired after an accident. Your only recourse is to ask or to sue.
Learn More
4 mins read

Subscribe to our newsletter

Stay on top of our latest offers, relevant news and tips!

Thanks for joining!

You'll be hearing from us shortly - stay tuned.