News & Resources

Survey: PC Financial Ranks First in Credit Card Customer Satisfaction

Sept. 13, 18
4 mins
A person holds a spread of credit cards in the background and a stack of coins is visible in the foreground

Reward and loyalty programs have become so popular over the years that, nowadays, it’s become the norm for a credit card to offer points and cash-back as incentive to the consumer. According to the J.D. Power 2018 Canada Credit Card Satisfaction Study, 87% of Canadian credit cardholders are enrolled in a loyalty program.  

The inaugural study looked into Canadian credit cardholder behaviours, evaluating their level of satisfaction with several providers and measuring what sparks their decision to apply for a specific card. And nearly half (48%) of cardholders who switched their primary credit card in the last year did it specifically for a better rewards program.     

This likely comes as no surprise since merchants, as well as credit card issuers want your business, and are constantly finding more ways to incentivize their products.   

Rewards redemption and frequency 

Having the ability to collect rewards is excellent, but the frequency at which you can redeem your credit card rewards is what matters more to Canadians.

According to the survey, satisfaction was the highest among those who redeemed points in the past month. Those who made a redemption in the last one to three months fell not too far behind in terms of satisfaction in the program. On the other hand, cardholders who made a redemption more than a year ago or have yet to claim anything at all were below the average when it comes to level of customer satisfaction. 

With regard to specific issuers, President’s Choice Financial ranked highest in overall customer satisfaction. They offer three no-fee credit cards that earn additional points at Shoppers Drug Mart and wherever President’s Choice products are sold.

To make a redemption, you only need 10,000 points to claim $10 in groceries, makeup, or merchandise at PC-affiliated stores. And the PC Financial World Elite Mastercard earns you the most points since you’ll get 30 points per dollar spent at participating stores where President’s Choice products are sold and 45 points per dollar spent at Shoppers Drug Mart.  

Confusion in how loyalty programs work 

The study also found that 64% of cardholders completely understood how to redeem their rewards. Understandably, customer satisfaction was higher compared to those who didn’t fully understand how their rewards system works. 

For example, certain loyalty programs have received flak in the past from consumers for their lack of transparency and confusion within the program. More recently, Aeroplan made headlines when it was announced that Air Canada made a deal with Aimia to acquire Aeroplan, though it was just last year that Air Canada made the decision to pull out of Aeroplan so it could launch its own loyalty program.  

The lack of seat availability and high fees associated with Aeroplan rewards were likely part of the reason why CIBC and TD Canada Trust (two of the major Aeroplan credit card partners) ranked at the bottom of the customer satisfaction survey.  

On the other hand, American Express ranked number two on the customer satisfaction scale. Amex has a variety of credit cards, but one line that really appeals to Canadians are the SimplyCash cards. Sticking true to its name, these cards simply offer cash-back as your reward, so there’s no confusion about how the loyalty program works.  

TheSimplyCash Card from American Express has no annual fee and gives you 2.5% in cash-back (up to $150) for the first three months of card membership. Once the promotional period ends, you’ll earn 1.25% in cash-back on all purchases, which can still add up to a few hundreds by the end of the year, depending on how often you use the card.  There’s also the SimplyCash Preferred Card from American Express which offers a higher earn rate at 5% cash-back (up to $300) in the first six months of card membership. There is an annual fee of $99, but if you use the card to its full potential, you can easily recoup that cost plus more. You’ll also earn 2% cash-back on all purchases once your promotional period ends. 

Two is better than one 

Contrary to the cultural belief that having too much credit is bad, it’s actually pretty common for Canadians to have two different credit cards in their wallet. The survey found that 81% of Canadians charge their total spend to a primary card while using a secondary card when needed.  

The idea of having a backup card is nothing new, but it appears Canadians are becoming smarter about which cards to use. A backup card may offer additional benefits at select merchants that your primary card may not. 

For example, Canadian Tire carries the Triangle World Elite Mastercard, which gives you four per cent cash back in Canadian Tire Money when you shop at Canadian Tire, Sport Chek, and participating Marks/L’Équipeur and Atmosphere locations. Also, you can get no-fee, no-interest financing on qualifying purchases of $200 or more at the same merchants. You may not want to use this card for primary spending, but there are huge incentives to using it if you shop at Canadian Tire and its partners on a regular basis.  

The mobile experience matters 

Regular use of mobile banking apps in Canada has substantially grown as of recent, with more than half (51%) of credit card holders having claimed to use an app to manage their account, redeem rewards, and take advantage of other benefits within the last three months. Gen Z leads the pack with a 79% mobile adoption rate.

Security is still a concern for many people, though, as only 41% of those surveyed felt that their personal information is secure on apps. Overall, those who fully understood how to use their mobile app gave higher customer satisfaction ratings.  

Although credit card providers have increased their offers over the years, the survey shed light on key factors to maintaining customer satisfaction. It came to a surprise to many that none of the big banks placed first in terms of issuer satisfaction, so it just goes to show that rewards alone are not enough to keep people happy. 

Keeping things simple with a loyalty program and mobile app that are easy to understand may be key factors for years to come.  

Barry Choi

Barry Choi is a personal finance and budget travel expert at Moneywehave.com. He has been quoted by media in Canada and the United States including The Financial Post, The Toronto Star, Business Insider, The Globe and Mail, and has appeared on HuffPost Live.

Latest life insurance articles
How Does Vaping and e-Cigarettes Affect Life Insurance?
Many insurers may classify vaping in the same way they do smoking. If you smoke or vape, you can still qualify for a life insurance premium, but in all likelihood, you will pay a higher rate than someone who does not.
Credit Life Insurance: Is It Worth It?
You’re a new homebuyer in the final stages of closing a mortgage. Suddenly the lender rep asks if you want to take out a life insurance policy for your mortgage. Do you take it?
What Not to Do Before a Life Insurance Medical Exam
The night before a medical exam for your life insurance is important and shouldn’t be taken lightly.