News & Resources

What to do if you suspect your mechanic is making fraudulent repair charges

Sept. 23, 2022
5 mins
Mechanic working on a car in the shop

In 2017, Aviva Canada did an undercover investigation to expose fraud in the automotive repair industry. The insurance provider purchased 10 cars, purposely damaged them, and then had experts estimate the cost of repairs.

Aviva’s team evaluated the collective damage to be approximately $30,000. However, when they took the cars to the repair shops, they were quoted close to $60,000. The investigation concluded that nine out of 10 repairs involved fraud and an estimated 57% of the total costs billed to Aviva were fraudulent.

While the results of this investigation might seem to highlight a problem that affects only insurance providers, repair fraud trickles down to the consumer, too. Being overcharged for a repair can increase the cost of your insurance claim and potentially affect your car insurance premium when your policy renews. Insurance fraud costs Canadians more than $1 billion each year, and if an insurance provider loses money to fraudulent claims one year, it may raise its premiums the next year to recoup some of those losses.

Fortunately, there are a few ways to alert yourself to the signs of a fraudulent auto body shop and avoid a faulty repair.

What to look for when it comes to auto repair fraud

To avoid paying for fraudulent auto repairs, watch out for these common tactics the next time you need to have your vehicle fixed.

Saying you need more work done than expected

People often go into repair shops looking for a simple repair only to be told there are several other “urgent” problems that need to be fixed. Mechanics can use scare tactics to get unsuspecting customers to authorize and pay for unnecessary repairs. For example, you may go in for a routine oil change only to be told that you need new brakes immediately — and no one wants to drive a car with faulty brakes.

If you’re skeptical about additional repairs recommended by your mechanic, get them to explain what the problem is and ask if you can see the broken part. If they give you roundabout answers, get angry, or refuse to show you the defect, this could be a red flag and you should seek a second opinion.

Premature replacements

The manual from your vehicle’s manufacturer lays out a set of milestones for when to have various parts replaced. If your repair shop is suggesting you need to replace a part of your vehicle, it’s in your best interest to look through your manual to see when the manufacturer recommends the part should be replaced. If your mechanic is suggesting you replace the part prematurely, this may be a sign you’re being ripped off.

Vague explanations

If you bring your car into a shop for a specific issue and your mechanic prescribes a plethora of repairs without being able to clearly explain what the problem is, this may be a sign of repair fraud. Dishonest mechanics can use jargon and vague terminology to confuse customers so they will authorize unnecessary repairs that seem legitimate. Before getting out your credit card, mechanics should be able to tell you exactly what the problem is and what needs to be fixed.

What to do if you suspect you’ve been scammed by your repair shop

If you think you’ve been scammed by your auto repair shop, your first step is to report it to local authorities.

“If you suspect your mechanic is creating fraudulent repairs or charges, it is recommended to gather as much data and information as possible and contact Consumer Protection Ontario,” says Nadia Matos, manager of external communications at CAA South Central Ontario.

Consumer Protection Ontario is a provincial program that works to enforce the rights of consumers by enforcing public safety laws and investigating filed violations.

“In these situations, it is also good to contact the fraud division of your police department,” says Matos.

Filing a police report can help target organized crime groups and help create proactive strategies to prevent fraud long term. You can also contact your insurance company and/or file a complaint with the Insurance Bureau of Canada.

How to find a reputable repair shop in Canada

Using recommended body shops is one of the best ways to be proactive against repair fraud. Minimizing this risk can help you maintain a lower premium, as can comparing car insurance rates annually to ensure you’re not overpaying for your policy. You can find recommended body shops by speaking with your insurance company, a trusted friend, or reading reviews online.

Each insurance company has a list of preferred body shops that they recommend to their customers. While you’re not obligated to bring your vehicle to a preferred shop following a claim, you can find peace of mind knowing that these shops have been evaluated by insurance companies and chosen by providing accurate estimates and high standards of repair and service. Using the body shops recommended by your insurance company can ensure you don’t unknowingly seek out the work of a fraudulent mechanic.

Interested in creating content with RATESDOTCA? Reach us at email@rates.ca.

car mascot.png

Don't waste time calling around for auto insurance

Use RATESDOTCA to shop around, and compare multiple quotes at the same time.

Julia Stratton

Julia Stratton is a freelance writer living in Ottawa. When she’s not writing, you can find her curled up with a book, running, or cooking up adventurous new recipes in the kitchen.

Latest auto insurance articles

What is the difference between an insurance agent and broker?
The terms “insurance agent” and “insurance broker” are often used interchangeably, but there are key differences between the two that matter when looking for an affordable auto insurance policy.
Learn More
3 mins read
1-in-5 Canadians are driving to work more often, but 74% unaware they must inform their insurance provider
As your weekly commute drives up your kilometre count, your auto insurance provider can’t be the last to know. Failing to report a change in vehicle usage can have serious repercussions on your policy.
Learn More
6 mins read
5 expensive car insurance mistakes
Distracted driving. Failing to report a change in the usage of your vehicle. Lying about where you live. These are just some of the mistakes that can result in a higher insurance premium.
Learn More
5 mins read

Subscribe to our newsletter

Stay on top of our latest offers, relevant news and tips!

Thanks for joining!

You'll be hearing from us shortly - stay tuned.