News & Resources

Does a claim on a car share vehicle affect your personal auto insurance policy?

April 22, 2022
4 mins
A row of silver and white cars parked in a lot

Owning a vehicle is expensive. The monthly payments, the insurance premium, the ongoing maintenance, the ever increasing price of gas, and other expenses all add up to a significant part of many people’s budgets. Which is just one reason why car sharing is gaining in popularity.

Services such as Zipcar and Communauto make it easy to grab a vehicle when you need one, without the hassle that typically comes with owning a vehicle. Especially for those living in a major urban centre, car sharing can make a lot of sense. But, there are some things you should know about when it comes to using a car sharing service and your insurance.

How car sharing impacts your driving record

Tanisha Kishan, RATESDOTCA expert and chartered insurance professional, says that any time a person signs up for a car sharing service, during the period of time when the vehicle is being delivered and driven under the terms of the car sharing agreement, any damage caused by accidents will fall under the commercial insurance policy. This is the case whether you’re the lender of a vehicle or a driver.

“However, this doesn't necessarily mean that it won't affect your personal auto insurance premium if you get in an accident while driving the car sharing vehicle,” says Kishan. “Both accidents and driving infractions, such as speeding tickets, can potentially impact your personal auto insurance policy."

This is something to keep in mind if you don't currently have an insurance policy but one day will, as it means that your driver’s abstract could have a record of any collision, which insurance providers would see when you apply for coverage.

How a claim on a car share vehicle can impact your insurance rate

Another thing to keep in mind, Kishan cautions, is that how you drive when you’re behind the wheel of a car share vehicle can also impact your car insurance rate. Tickets for behaviours like speeding or distracted driving will cause your rate to increase, no matter whose vehicle you’re driving.

“Because you are ticketed as an individual, any tickets you incur while driving a car share vehicle will impact your personal auto insurance policy," says Kishan.

Some of these car sharing companies' memberships include what’s known as “secondary insurance.” If you have your own auto insurance, you can often bring that with you if you have the provision of rental car coverage. This is known as your primary coverage. However, most car share companies also provide their own insurance “secondary” to your primary policy. This can provide additional coverage while you’re using the car share vehicle. If you don’t have personal insurance coverage, however, you’re still covered under the car share company’s policy.

Coverage from the car share company: what you need to know

Keep in mind that not abiding by the terms and conditions of your car share contract can mean the company doesn’t cover you in the event of a collision. For example, allowing a non-member to drive the vehicle can void your insurance coverage through Zipcar.

Additionally, many car share companies offer what’s known as a damage fee waiver or damage protection plan. This is available at an additional cost, and helps to cover your financial responsibility for damages arising from your use of the vehicle (usually a set fee per event).

Before purchasing a damage fee waiver or protection plan, you should check to see if you already have rental vehicle collision coverage through a credit card or personal automobile insurance policy that would apply to and cover the damage fee. A damage fee waiver or protection plan is not insurance and does not provide or alter your insurance coverage.

Finally, always be sure to read the fine print of any car sharing company’s agreement, as coverage levels will vary depending on your province or territory of residence, as well as the provider.

"The car insurance that car share companies offer will depend on what insurance provider they use,” says Kishan. “Make sure to read the fine print so you know what you're signing up for."

car mascot.png

Don't waste time calling around for auto insurance

Use RATESDOTCA to shop around, and compare multiple quotes at the same time.

Caitlin McCormack

Caitlin McCormack is a writer based in Toronto. Her work has appeared in MSN, Food Network, HuffPost, What to Expect, Today's Parent, and Mashable, among others. When she isn't writing, she's busy chasing after her two sons, testing out new recipes, and working on her century-old fixer-upper.

Latest auto insurance articles

Can you negotiate the price of a used car in today's market?
Negotiating the price of a used vehicle today can be tough. But there are other ways of maximizing your vehicle's value, long-term.
Learn More
4 mins read
5 road safety tips for the Victoria Day weekend
If you intend to take a road trip for the May long weekend, here are five road safety tips to keep in mind before shifting into drive.
Learn More
4 mins read
How auto insurance works if you hit a cyclist or pedestrian
Your auto insurance can protect you after a collision with a cyclist or pedestrian — but you may need added coverage.
Learn More
6 mins read

Subscribe to our newsletter

Stay on top of our latest offers, relevant news and tips!

Thanks for joining!

You'll be hearing from us shortly - stay tuned.