News & Resources

How Not to Lose Money in Mortgages

April 28, 2021
5 mins
An agent directs a young couple to fill out paperwork

After watching interest rates for 14 years you learn a valuable lesson. The experts know bugger-all about where rates will be two years from now.

They may sound supremely confident. They may even have a better-than-even chance of getting rate direction right, but they have utterly no inkling of future rate-change magnitude or the duration of future rate peaks.

The reasons are simple: economies are unfathomably complex and random events change the path of interest rates in unknowable ways.

That’s why you have to shake your head when you see videos of mortgage advisors pushing variable mortgages on this basis → that borrowers can convert to a fixed rate before variable rates increase.

Benjamin Graham quote.jpg

I recently saw a broker on YouTube. He was encouraging people to go variable and "consider locking in" if "interest rates look like they'll start going up."

Due to the Bank of Canada’s highly publicized forward guidance (that rates will stay low till 2023), this broker proclaimed, "We know what's going to happen for the next 2-3 years..."

Whaa? How does that work? Last anyone checked, mortgage salespeople aren't prophets.

And even if this broker did notice bond yields making new highs — a precursor to short-term moves in fixed rates — and even if he did tell clients to lock in when that happened:

  • Would borrowers lock in quickly enough?
    • Probably not, without some rate slippage — i.e., without rates rising before they pulled the trigger
  • Would they get a lousy conversion rate from their existing lender who knows they must pay a penalty to leave?
    • Very likely
    • Note: a "conversion rate" is the fixed rate the lender offers when you move out of a variable rate.
  • Could rates fall right back down within months of the borrower locking in?
    • Quite possibly.

When the BoC re-forecast its rate-hike timeframe last week from 2023 to 2022, it should have been an alarm bell for everyone who thinks they have an edge in rate timing. All the advisors who indiscriminately pushed variables because rates will “stay low for three years,” they're probably not the experts many think they are. How could they be? Not even the Bank of Canada with more rate analytics and data than you could ever imagine knew it would need to significantly move forward its rate-hike expectations.

The best we can all do is manage risk.

Odds are, we’re near the trough of an interest rate cycle—assuming you believe forward interest rates in the bond market. In the trough of an interest rate cycle, people manage risk by taking the lowest-cost longer-term flexible mortgage product they can find. And they choose a fair penalty lender in case they need to break the mortgage early.

This is how most folks who need financing for 5+ years should be playing the interest rate game today.

If you’re wrong and rates, against all odds, do not rise significantly from here, the opportunity cost of not choosing a variable will be modest. That's because:

(A) the fixed-variable spread is narrower than usual, and
(B) floating rates are likely to see a minimum of 2-3 hikes in the next few years (based on the stimulus-led recovery and implied pricing in the bond market).

On the other hand, if you go fixed — instead of floating — and rates normalize, you could save serious dollars versus a variable, or a variable that locks into a fixed.

Today's Featured RatesUpdated 17:24 ET on Nov 26, 2021

Rates are based on a $300,000 mortgage.

card image
2.44%
Term
5 Yr Fixed
Loan to value
Up to 80%
Insurance
Uninsured
Rate held until
Feb 25
card image
1.73%
Term
5 Yr Fixed
Loan to value
Up to 65%
Insurance
Insurable
Rate held until
Jan 11
card image
2.50%
Term
5 Yr Fixed
Loan to value
80.01% to 95%
Insurance
Insured
Rate held until
Feb 25

The Long and Short of It

Trading in financial markets is one of the hardest occupations to be good at on the face of the planet. Locking in a mortgage at the right time is essentially trading (swapping a floating rate for a fixed one).

I’ve earned a living analyzing interest rates for well over a decade. But I have zero ability to tell you with confidence that:

  • rates won’t go up next year
  • you should therefore choose a variable or short-term fixed mortgage.

Nor can any other mortgage broker or banker.

If you're going to float your mortgage, do it because a variable is the most suitable term for other reasons, not because it's got a "free" rate lock option.

Rob McLister

Rob McLister has been informing mortgage consumers and professionals since 2007. In that time, he’s written more than 2,500 mortgage stories for publications ranging from the Globe and Mail — where he presently serves as mortgage columnist — to the National Post, Maclean’s, Canadian Mortgage Trends and RateSpy.com. Regularly quoted throughout the media, Rob is a committed advocate of greater transparency in the mortgage industry. He’s also been a vocal consumer advocate for more sensible mortgage regulation. In 2011, he launched two mortgage fintechs: mortgage comparison website RateSpy.com and digital mortgage broker intelliMortgage Inc. The former is the go-to source of Canadian mortgage news and the only site comparing all publicly advertised prime mortgage rates. The latter is Canada's leading online mortgage provider for self-directed borrowers. Both companies were acquired in 2019 by RATESDOTCA Group Ltd.

Latest life insurance articles

10 Myths About Life Insurance Busted – Some May Surprise You
You may be young with no kids and no mortgage. Life insurance is for someone older, who has dependents right? Wrong. Let’s debunk life insurance myths and learn why everyone needs some form of coverage.
Learn More
6 mins read
Will a Life Insurance Policy Cover Death Due to COVID-19?
Demand for life insurance may be on the rise during the pandemic as more Canadians consider buying a policy or reviewing ones they already have. If you’re thinking of applying for a policy, here are a few things to keep in mind.
Learn More
4 mins read
How Does Vaping and e-Cigarettes Affect Life Insurance?
Many insurers may classify vaping in the same way they do smoking. If you smoke or vape, you can still qualify for a life insurance premium, but in all likelihood, you will pay a higher rate than someone who does not.
Learn More
4 mins read